Can sed produce output in the form of text file(s) all by itself as long as the input came from STDIN?

What the title says: assuming sed reads from STDIN¹ could its output be a text file ?

Just to be clear, I'm not talking about saving sed's output to a text file via shell operators like >, >> or using tools like tee etc.

The question here is whether sed alone can produce output in the form of text file(s) and if so, under which circumstances ?

^{1: this is simply to rule out any in-place editing of a text file with implementations that support it.}

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

If the question is about being able to redirect sed's output from within sed (the accepted reply suggests that), then please change the title and the text of your question to reflect it; the argument to the w command of sed doesn' t have to be a "text file"; it could be a character device, pipe, socket, etc.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 14:14

@pizdelect - there's nothing to change, really: the question is whether sed alone can produce a text file and if so how / when does that happen. If you still don't understand it then feel free to down-vote it. If you already did so, then enjoy your vote.

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:07

1

Changing the question to something more relevant and precise would help people looking for info -- for instance, even the text from your comment "whether sed alone can produce (create?) a (text) file ..." is MUCH better than the one from the question ;-)

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 20:49

@pizdelect - if you take the time to read the question it says exactly that but whatever, I'll edit it... is it better now ?

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 20:53

add a comment |

^{1: this is simply to rule out any in-place editing of a text file with implementations that support it.}

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

If the question is about being able to redirect sed's output from within sed (the accepted reply suggests that), then please change the title and the text of your question to reflect it; the argument to the w command of sed doesn' t have to be a "text file"; it could be a character device, pipe, socket, etc.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 14:14

@pizdelect - there's nothing to change, really: the question is whether sed alone can produce a text file and if so how / when does that happen. If you still don't understand it then feel free to down-vote it. If you already did so, then enjoy your vote.

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:07

1

Changing the question to something more relevant and precise would help people looking for info -- for instance, even the text from your comment "whether sed alone can produce (create?) a (text) file ..." is MUCH better than the one from the question ;-)

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 20:49

@pizdelect - if you take the time to read the question it says exactly that but whatever, I'll edit it... is it better now ?

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 20:53

add a comment |

^{1: this is simply to rule out any in-place editing of a text file with implementations that support it.}

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

^{1: this is simply to rule out any in-place editing of a text file with implementations that support it.}

sed

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

edited Jan 10 at 21:05

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

asked Jan 10 at 12:21

don_crissti

51.3k15137165

If the question is about being able to redirect sed's output from within sed (the accepted reply suggests that), then please change the title and the text of your question to reflect it; the argument to the w command of sed doesn' t have to be a "text file"; it could be a character device, pipe, socket, etc.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 14:14

@pizdelect - there's nothing to change, really: the question is whether sed alone can produce a text file and if so how / when does that happen. If you still don't understand it then feel free to down-vote it. If you already did so, then enjoy your vote.

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:07

1

Changing the question to something more relevant and precise would help people looking for info -- for instance, even the text from your comment "whether sed alone can produce (create?) a (text) file ..." is MUCH better than the one from the question ;-)

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 20:49

@pizdelect - if you take the time to read the question it says exactly that but whatever, I'll edit it... is it better now ?

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 20:53

add a comment |

If the question is about being able to redirect sed's output from within sed (the accepted reply suggests that), then please change the title and the text of your question to reflect it; the argument to the w command of sed doesn' t have to be a "text file"; it could be a character device, pipe, socket, etc.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 14:14

@pizdelect - there's nothing to change, really: the question is whether sed alone can produce a text file and if so how / when does that happen. If you still don't understand it then feel free to down-vote it. If you already did so, then enjoy your vote.

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:07

1

Changing the question to something more relevant and precise would help people looking for info -- for instance, even the text from your comment "whether sed alone can produce (create?) a (text) file ..." is MUCH better than the one from the question ;-)

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 20:49

@pizdelect - if you take the time to read the question it says exactly that but whatever, I'll edit it... is it better now ?

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 20:53

If the question is about being able to redirect sed's output from within sed (the accepted reply suggests that), then please change the title and the text of your question to reflect it; the argument to the w command of sed doesn' t have to be a "text file"; it could be a character device, pipe, socket, etc.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 14:14

@pizdelect - there's nothing to change, really: the question is whether sed alone can produce a text file and if so how / when does that happen. If you still don't understand it then feel free to down-vote it. If you already did so, then enjoy your vote.

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:07

Changing the question to something more relevant and precise would help people looking for info -- for instance, even the text from your comment "whether sed alone can produce (create?) a (text) file ..." is MUCH better than the one from the question ;-)

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 20:49

@pizdelect - if you take the time to read the question it says exactly that but whatever, I'll edit it... is it better now ?

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 20:53

add a comment |

1 Answer
1

active

oldest

votes

Yes, using the w command, or the w flag to the s command, both of which are specified by POSIX.

For example, with

sed -n 'w output.txt'

anything fed into sed’s standard input will be written to output.txt, with no output to sed’s standard output (thanks to the -n option). This can be combined with other commands to manipulate the pattern space before writing it out.

A few notes of warning and recommendations:

If the file name starts with a blank, use a ./ prefix:

sed -n 'w ./ output with blanks.txt'

If the file name contains newline characters, POSIXly, you can escape them with backslash, though it won't work with all sed implementations (in particular, not with GNU sed nor busybox sed):

sed -n 'w ./output

with

newline.txt'

If it contains backslash characters, in some implementations (the POSIX ones above that support newlines in file names), you need to escape them with backslash:

sed -n 'w file\with\backslash.txt' # POSIX

sed -n 'w filewithbackslash.txt'   # GNU

Also note that the output file will be created (or truncated) even if the input is empty or the w command is never run like in:

sed 'd;w file'

seq 20 | sed '/21/ w file'

You may want to use awk instead to avoid this kind of problems

FILE=arbitrary-file-name awk '/100/ {print > ENVIRON["FILE"]}'

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

2

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

add a comment |

Your Answer

StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "106"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});

}
});

draft saved

draft discarded

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2funix.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f493697%2fcan-sed-produce-output-in-the-form-of-text-files-all-by-itself-as-long-as-the%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

1 Answer
1

active

oldest

votes

1 Answer
1

active

oldest

votes

Yes, using the w command, or the w flag to the s command, both of which are specified by POSIX.

For example, with

sed -n 'w output.txt'

A few notes of warning and recommendations:

If the file name starts with a blank, use a ./ prefix:

sed -n 'w ./ output with blanks.txt'

If the file name contains newline characters, POSIXly, you can escape them with backslash, though it won't work with all sed implementations (in particular, not with GNU sed nor busybox sed):

sed -n 'w ./output

with

newline.txt'

If it contains backslash characters, in some implementations (the POSIX ones above that support newlines in file names), you need to escape them with backslash:

sed -n 'w file\with\backslash.txt' # POSIX

sed -n 'w filewithbackslash.txt'   # GNU

Also note that the output file will be created (or truncated) even if the input is empty or the w command is never run like in:

sed 'd;w file'

seq 20 | sed '/21/ w file'

You may want to use awk instead to avoid this kind of problems

FILE=arbitrary-file-name awk '/100/ {print > ENVIRON["FILE"]}'

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

2

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

add a comment |

Yes, using the w command, or the w flag to the s command, both of which are specified by POSIX.

For example, with

sed -n 'w output.txt'

A few notes of warning and recommendations:

If the file name starts with a blank, use a ./ prefix:

sed -n 'w ./ output with blanks.txt'

If the file name contains newline characters, POSIXly, you can escape them with backslash, though it won't work with all sed implementations (in particular, not with GNU sed nor busybox sed):

sed -n 'w ./output

with

newline.txt'

If it contains backslash characters, in some implementations (the POSIX ones above that support newlines in file names), you need to escape them with backslash:

sed -n 'w file\with\backslash.txt' # POSIX

sed -n 'w filewithbackslash.txt'   # GNU

Also note that the output file will be created (or truncated) even if the input is empty or the w command is never run like in:

sed 'd;w file'

seq 20 | sed '/21/ w file'

You may want to use awk instead to avoid this kind of problems

FILE=arbitrary-file-name awk '/100/ {print > ENVIRON["FILE"]}'

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

2

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

add a comment |

Yes, using the w command, or the w flag to the s command, both of which are specified by POSIX.

For example, with

sed -n 'w output.txt'

A few notes of warning and recommendations:

If the file name starts with a blank, use a ./ prefix:

sed -n 'w ./ output with blanks.txt'

If the file name contains newline characters, POSIXly, you can escape them with backslash, though it won't work with all sed implementations (in particular, not with GNU sed nor busybox sed):

sed -n 'w ./output

with

newline.txt'

If it contains backslash characters, in some implementations (the POSIX ones above that support newlines in file names), you need to escape them with backslash:

sed -n 'w file\with\backslash.txt' # POSIX

sed -n 'w filewithbackslash.txt'   # GNU

Also note that the output file will be created (or truncated) even if the input is empty or the w command is never run like in:

sed 'd;w file'

seq 20 | sed '/21/ w file'

You may want to use awk instead to avoid this kind of problems

FILE=arbitrary-file-name awk '/100/ {print > ENVIRON["FILE"]}'

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

Yes, using the w command, or the w flag to the s command, both of which are specified by POSIX.

For example, with

sed -n 'w output.txt'

A few notes of warning and recommendations:

If the file name starts with a blank, use a ./ prefix:

sed -n 'w ./ output with blanks.txt'

If the file name contains newline characters, POSIXly, you can escape them with backslash, though it won't work with all sed implementations (in particular, not with GNU sed nor busybox sed):

sed -n 'w ./output

with

newline.txt'

If it contains backslash characters, in some implementations (the POSIX ones above that support newlines in file names), you need to escape them with backslash:

sed -n 'w file\with\backslash.txt' # POSIX

sed -n 'w filewithbackslash.txt'   # GNU

Also note that the output file will be created (or truncated) even if the input is empty or the w command is never run like in:

sed 'd;w file'

seq 20 | sed '/21/ w file'

You may want to use awk instead to avoid this kind of problems

FILE=arbitrary-file-name awk '/100/ {print > ENVIRON["FILE"]}'

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

edited Jan 10 at 13:02

Stéphane Chazelas

308k57581939

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

answered Jan 10 at 12:27

Stephen Kitt

174k24398473

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

2

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

add a comment |

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

2

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

also the w flag of the s/// command. A standard sed can use a file name in the r and w commands or as an argument to the w flag of s///. This has security implication, because you cannot pledge the sed command as being just a filter.

– pizdelect
Jan 10 at 12:35

See also the W command of GNU sed.

– Stéphane Chazelas
Jan 10 at 13:06

Thanks for confirming my statement ! ;)

– don_crissti
Jan 10 at 19:37

add a comment |

draft saved

draft discarded

Thanks for contributing an answer to Unix & Linux Stack Exchange!

Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid …

Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.

draft saved

draft discarded

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

Sign up or log in

StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});

Post as a guest

Name

Required, but never shown

Name

Required, but never shown

Name

Required, but never shown

This page is only for reference, If you need detailed information, please check here

搜尋此網誌

Dtyjlui